Am i a good man?Peter Capaldi’s run as the medical professional is coming to a close. With Jodie Whittaker poised come take over in the Christmas distinct this December, the is time to say goodbye to doctor number 12. However first, I desire to take it a look ago at a information of his operation that i don’t think a lot world have talked about.

You are watching: Run you clever boy and be a doctor

Throughout Peter Capaldi’s entire run that Doctor Who there has actually been a template of remembering. In ~ first, I thought that to be a trouble with the series, since his very first episode began with him no remembering that he is, as shown in these clips indigenous the show: first, when he initially regenerates, and again once he first appears in his very first full episode, “Deep Breath.” he asked Clara, “Am ns a good man?” He doesn’t seem to remember his vault regenerations, the doesn’t also seem to remember that he faced the clockwork droids once he was the 10th Doctor. And I tho think the was a misstep the they didn’t discover that additional in his very first season. This ide of him no remembering or having actually to relearn that he is.

I mean, it makes sense, offered that this is a brand brand-new regeneration cycle, and Capaldi’s doctor is the very first Doctor in that cycle, it makes sense the he is disconnected, to part extent, from his previous selves, even if that link can be, eventually, repaired. And while “Deep Breath” was a an excellent episode (and one of Capaldi’s best), what they collection up in it- the physician not remembering who he to be before- never seemed to acquire its early in the adhering to episodes. Even by the finish of the episode, he seemed to psychic what he necessary to. And also that to be something that ns felt was a weak in his first series, the they had this cool concept and also then they just dropped that after his an initial episode.

But looking at Capaldi’s entire run, and even the imminent Christmas Special, i realize currently that his entire run of medical professional Who has actually been around remembering, to some version of the idea.

Let’s look at a few big moment in Capaldi’s run that support this. Obviously, there’s his introduction, and there’s Clara’s presence (“Run girlfriend clever boy, and also remember.”), as the 11th medical professional requests she aid 12 remember that he is, and also Capaldi depends on her to tell that if the is a good man or not. Yet of course, Clara’s fate really pulls us ago to this design template with a dramatic twist.



Run friend clever boy, and also remember.

If you look at the orgasm of series 9, the entirety thing comes down to the Doctor and also Clara, where one is going to remember and also the other is going come forget (in a way mirroring Donna Noble’s fate), and it end up being that Clara will certainly remember if the doctor forgets. And earlier in the series, when we an initial meet Ashildr (Me), and the doctor remembers why he offered himself Capaldi’s face, a face he had actually seen before, a confront he’s to be trying come remember because he regenerated (“Who frowned me this face?”). He establish he decided the challenge of the male whose family members he conserved in Pompeii. He was reminding himself the he’s the Doctor and he saves civilization (which is additionally a referral to a Donna Noble episode). It is his previous self telling his current self to remember that he was, to remember that, even if history says nobody lives, the is the person who saves world anyway.



Welcome to the Sisterhood.

But top top that totality theory of Capaldi’s run being about remembering, we have to look in ~ Missy… or the Master… in the final episode of series 10. Missy tells john Simm’s master that she doesn’t remember anything that’s going on in those episodes due to the fact that there’s two versions of herself/himself in the same location at the same time (wibbly wobbly timey wimey, comparable to why David Tennant’s Doctor and John Hurt’s physician wouldn’t mental the events of “Day of the Doctor.”). Missy tells the understand that she no remember meeting him… and also I think she lying. Very first off, she’s Missy. She’s the Master. She’s the Mistress. She lies much more than the medical professional lies (rule number one). Of food she remembers everything, or at the very least most everything, the is going come happen. She definitely remembers that she’s going to die soon, since when she stabbed the understand in the back, she knew full well that it to be going come happen, since she remembered being him, being stabbed by she (just prefer she remembered conference a crazy woman that told she to bring a spare component for she T.A.R.D.I.S.). And I think that similarly she remembered the she killed her future self. And I think that might go a long method to explaining her type of weird arc through collection 10, the truth that she’s on some sort of redemption path, even though that seems to it is in a path set forth by the Doctor, no herself. It definitely seems the she’s mindful that she coming to the finish (much favor the Doctor has felt he is coming to the end), since she to know this is her final form, that she death herself in this kind (in the same means River track knows she the final form of Melody Pond). So i think Missy certainly knew the entirety episode, most likely the totality season, if I had actually to guess, that she was coming to she end. It is why she was going v her whole “I am physician Who” phase. It also bookends well, v Missy’s an initial attack versus the medical professional (creating Cybermen on Earth) reflects John Simm’s Master’s final attack versus the Doctor.


You might be “a” doctor, yet I to be “the” Doctor. The original, you could say.

The template of psychic is walking to monitor through right into Capaldi’s last episode, v the presence of the an initial Doctor. I’m imagining that the entire episode will be following inside the Doctor’s head, during the renewal cycle. I don’t think he’s staved it off, choose we saw in the last episode of series 10. Ns think that is in complete regeneration explosion, and this Christmas unique will take place totally in his subconscious, enabling him come reflect with the very first Doctor. Permitting him to literally remember his previous self and conversate v him. Ns mean, an alert how the T.A.R.D.I.S. Simply seems to pause once he stop his regeneration. It’s favor that minute in time has actually frozen. But no issue whether I’m appropriate or wrong about that, we are in for a very interesting character study, having actually the Doctor interact with his original self, and that runs so deep within the theme of remembering.

See more: Which Of The Following Is Not A Type Of Plate Boundary? ? Chapter 4 Plate Tectonics Exam Flashcards

I’m sure there are plenty of other moments transparent his run that speak to the template of remembering. Small moments, here and also there, and also honestly every physician is walking to have those moments. That bound to occur when a display has run for fifty years. Yet if every Doctor has a template that ties their operation together, Capaldi’s, to me, is absolutely remembering. Beginning with his regeneration, his new face, and also Clara, and ending v Missy and also the Master and also the an initial Doctor, the reality that Capaldi’s physician is constantly trying to remember, or demands to remember, his previous is constantly present.

I’m sure remembering will continue to beat an interesting component in Jodie Whittaker’s operation as the Doctor. Obviously, she will certainly be bringing something brand-new and unique to the role, something us haven’t watch before, yet any great Doctor will always remember where he, or currently she, has actually been before. And it is always an excellent to psychic what came prior to you, let it educate you, but continue to relocate forward to brand-new and better things. Together Matt Smith placed it best:

“We all change, when you think about it, we’re all different people; all through our lives, and that’s okay, that’s good, you’ve gotta keep moving, so lengthy as friend remember every the human being that you offered to be. I will certainly not forget one line of this, no one day, i swear. I will constantly remember when The doctor was me.”

Extra Tidbits: i’m thrilled to view what Jodie Whittaker brings to the 13th Doctor. That said, looking ago on those clips I included of Donna Noble (it has actually been a lengthy time because I’ve gone ago and rewatching noþeles older 보다 Matt Smith), ns realize Catherine Tate would have actually been a good choice come play the Doctor, too. It would certainly be keeping in the design template that the physician is using deals with that he’s seen before (as it was hinted in “Day the the Doctor” that he might be revisiting a couple of old favorites). Of food I always thought Jenna Coleman could do good in the role, as well. Regardless, ns feel the future the Doctor Who is in safe hands. Good luck, Jodie Whittaker!

In the layout of remembering, walk you recognize that the fake face Capaldi wore in “Deep Breath” to mix in v the clockwork droids was in reality a mask that Matt Smith? examine it out: